Photo by Warren Griffiths on Unsplash
But Legally – Can You Take Them Elsewhere?
Who should read this article?
This article is for:
- Homeowners who have paid for house plans and want to use another builder.
- Builders who are asked to construct a house using plans prepared by a competitor.
- Architects and building designers who want to understand how copyright protects their work.
- Draftspersons asked to redraw or modify existing house plans.
- Property developers who want to reuse or adapt residential designs.
- Anyone building or renovating who want to make changes to existing plans.
Imagine this
You’ve spent months designing your dream home. You’ve met with a builder, discussed the kitchen, moved a few walls, added a study and finally settled on a design you love.
Then the quote arrives.
It’s more than you expected and a friend recommends another builder who says they can build something similar for less. You have paid for the drawings, so maybe its ok? Unfortunately, though, and this is the message in this blog, paying for plans does not necessarily mean you own the copyright in them. And changing a few things won’t necessarily solve the problem either.
Australian courts have dealt with disputes involving precisely these kinds of issues.
Two particularly interesting decisions are Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 46 and LED Builders Pty Ltd v Eagle Homes Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 633.
Both offer useful lessons about copying, modifying and reusing residential building designs.
They also show why architectural copyright disputes are rarely as straightforward as they first appear, and why understanding your legal rights before building, copying or modifying a design is really important.
First, who actually owns the house plans?
Under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), architectural drawings and plans can be protected as artistic works.
Copyright generally arises automatically when the relevant requirements are met. There is no Australian copyright registration system for house plans.
However, copyright ownership is a separate question from who paid for the drawings. Depending on the circumstances, the copyright may belong to the architect, designer, building company or another person or entity.
We have seen cases where the employee prepares drawings as part of their employment. There is the question as to whether the employer owns the copyright.
There is also the question of whether a homeowner who commissions plans has permission to use them for a particular purpose without acquiring copyright ownership (also known as a licence).
Case 1: Metricon v Barrett – the alfresco area that became a copyright dispute
Australians love an alfresco area. A covered outdoor space, preferably near the kitchen, has become almost a standard feature of the modern Australian home. So how did an alfresco area end up at the centre of a Federal Court copyright dispute?
The answer lies in the particular arrangement of the rooms around it.
In Metricon Homes Pty Ltd v Barrett Property Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 46, the dispute involved project-home designs developed by Barrett Property Group and designs subsequently used by Metricon.
Barrett, which trades as Porter Davis Homes, had a design called the Seattle. Its rear section brought together the kitchen and meals area, the family room, a rumpus room and a covered outdoor alfresco, all under a single roof-line.
The arrangement became known as the alfresco quadrant.
It was not simply the presence of an outdoor entertaining area that mattered. It was the way the various living spaces were brought together as part of the overall design.
Metricon later built a number of homes with a strikingly similar rear section. Barrett alleged that Metricon had reproduced a substantial part of its copyright-protected work.
The trial judge found that Metricon had deliberately copied the alfresco quadrant from the Seattle design. On appeal, Metricon did not dispute that copying had occurred. Its argument was that what it copied was too trivial to be a “substantial part”.
But aren’t all kitchens and living rooms rather similar?
To a degree, yes. Nobody owns the general idea of having a kitchen next to a dining room, or an outdoor entertaining area beside the family room. Copyright protects the original expression of an idea, rather than the idea itself.
But the particular arrangement of familiar features may form part of a protected artistic work. The Court therefore had to consider whether the material reproduced was a substantial part of Barrett’s work.
And this is where architectural copyright becomes interesting. A substantial part does not necessarily mean most of the drawing.
It can mean a smaller but qualitatively important part of the design.
What did the Court say?
The Full Federal Court examined the history of the Seattle design, including the drawings, revisions and discussions that led to the final arrangement. The judges rejected the suggestion that the relevant arrangement had simply appeared in a single sketch without significant design development.
They described the alfresco quadrant as:
“the product of considerable design evolution.”
The Court also referred to the part of the house that the trial judge had described as the:
“hub of the home”.
That is a rather fitting description. After all, the kitchen, family room and outdoor entertaining area are often precisely where a family spends much of its time.
Importantly, the Court emphasised that what matters most is the originality of the part copied, not how long it took to create. A highly original idea that comes to a designer in a flash can still be a substantial part of a plan.
The Court upheld the finding that Metricon had reproduced a substantial part of the protected work and dismissed the appeal. Differences in dimensions, kitchen details and the positions of doors and windows did not change that result.
What does Metricon teach us?
A builder cannot necessarily avoid copyright infringement by changing other parts of a house while retaining a substantial part of the original design.
For example, moving a bedroom, changing the garage or altering the façade may not resolve the issue if a significant protected arrangement has still been copied.
But the opposite is equally important. The fact that two houses contain similar rooms or follow the same architectural style does not automatically mean infringement has occurred.
The question is whether protected expression has actually been reproduced.
Case 2: When the changes themselves tell a story
The second case is particularly interesting because it shows how copyright infringement can arise even where a builder does not simply photocopy or trace another company’s drawings.
In LED Builders Pty Ltd v Eagle Homes Pty Ltd [1996] FCA 633, LED Builders, trading as Beechwood Homes, brought proceedings against Eagle Homes concerning residential floor plans.
The dispute involved several competing project-home designs. LED alleged that Eagle had copied substantial parts of its plans.
The Court examined the similarities between the drawings and the evidence about how Eagle’s designs had been created.
What if the plans aren’t identical?
This is where the case becomes particularly useful. Copyright infringement does not require an exact copy.
A drawing may reproduce a substantial part of another drawing even where there are differences in room dimensions, layout details or presentation.
But similarity alone is not enough. There must also be a relevant connection between the original work and the allegedly infringing work.
In other words, there must be a causal connection between the two works. Did Eagle actually use LED’s work, directly or indirectly, in developing its own designs?
That is a very different question from simply asking whether the houses look alike.
What did the evidence show?
The Court examined how Eagle’s plans had been developed. It found that Eagle’s managing director had given its draftsman instructions, both through sketches and verbally, which brought Eagle’s plans into line with LED’s designs.
The judge found that this amounted to deliberate copying by Eagle.
The changes Eagle made did not help. In one comparison, the main difference was an added rumpus room. In another, the laundry had simply moved. Neither was enough to avoid infringement.
Importantly, the copying had occurred through instructions to make changes, rather than by directly tracing one plan from another.
That distinction is worth remembering.
A person does not necessarily avoid infringement by asking somebody else to prepare a new drawing.
If the new drawing reproduces a substantial part of the earlier protected work, the fact that a different draftsperson held the pencil or operated the software may not resolve the copyright issue.
Why does LED Builders matter today?
Consider a homeowner who takes a competitor’s brochure to a builder and says:
“I love this design. Can you make me something very similar, but change the bedrooms and move the garage?”
The builder may prepare an entirely new set of drawings.
But the legal question is not simply whether the drawings are new documents. It is whether they reproduce a substantial part of the original protected expression.
The evidence of how the plans were developed, what materials were supplied and what instructions were given may become particularly important.
Of course, independent creation remains a legitimate answer to an infringement allegation where the evidence supports it.
Two designers may arrive at similar solutions because they are working with similar blocks of land, building requirements, budgets or customer preferences.
Copyright does not prohibit independent creation.
Why architectural copyright law isn’t always black and white
If only copyright law were as simple as looking at two sets of house plans and counting the differences. Unfortunately, it isn’t and the reason for this is that two houses can look remarkably similar without copyright infringement having occurred. Equally, two plans can look quite different and still raise infringement concerns.
That’s because Australian copyright law involves several overlapping questions. Is the original design protected by copyright? Who owns that copyright? Has a substantial part been reproduced? Was there actually copying? And what permission, if any, was given to use the plans?
The answers are not always obvious.
And just to complicate matters further, the legal position may differ depending on whether the dispute concerns the drawings, a modified version of the drawings or a building constructed from them.
This is why architectural copyright disputes often require more than a side-by-side comparison of floor plans. They can involve detailed legal analysis, design histories, contractual interpretation and evidence about how a particular design came into existence.
What looks like a simple disagreement about a few walls can quickly become a much larger legal problem.
Isn’t there a rule that changing 10% makes it legal?
No.
There is no general 10% rule, 20% rule or any other magic percentage that makes copying lawful under Australian copyright law.
This misconception appears regularly in discussions about house plans, photographs and other creative works.
Changing a particular percentage of an existing design does not automatically remove the risk of infringement.
Under section 14 of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), the concept of reproduction includes reproduction of a substantial part of a work.
The question is not simply how many lines, rooms or measurements have changed. The quality and significance of what has been reproduced matter.
For example, a designer might alter half the bedrooms in a house but retain a particularly distinctive and important arrangement of living spaces.
Conversely, two houses might share many commonplace features without one being copied from the other.
The law requires more than a numerical comparison.
Fun facts: when house plans go to court
- An alfresco area became a legal battleground. In Metricon v Barrett, the arrangement of rooms around a covered outdoor entertaining area was central to the copyright dispute.
- You don’t have to trace a drawing to copy it. In LED Builders v Eagle Homes, the Court found copying through instructions given to draftspersons.
- There is no magic percentage. Changing 10%, 20% or even more of a plan does not automatically make it safe to use. Copyright is not concerned with a mathematical formula.
- A house can be a reproduction of a drawing. Under section 21(3) of the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), reproducing a two-dimensional artistic work in three-dimensional form may constitute reproduction. That is why building from protected plans can raise copyright issues.
- Two houses can look similar without infringement. Copyright does not prevent two people from independently creating similar designs.
Similar homes are common in new estates. Similarity alone isn’t infringement – the question is whether a design was copied, and whether a substantial part was taken. | Photo from Terrah Holly and Warren Griffith from unsplash
What if the new builder redraws everything?
A new set of drawings doesn’t necessarily mean a fresh start.
Whether redrawn plans raise a copyright problem can turn on factors such as:
- how much of the original design has been carried across, and how important that part is
- how the new plans were developed, and what instructions were given
- what records exist of the design process.
Similar plans are not automatically infringing, and different-looking plans are not automatically safe. Working out which side of the line a design falls on takes legal analysis, not a side-by-side comparison.
Could a homeowner be liable too?
Possibly. Liability isn’t always limited to whoever prepares the drawings. Someone who supplies plans, gives instructions or authorises their use may also need to consider their position. In Metricon, for example, individuals were found personally liable alongside the company.
Whether this could apply to you depends on the circumstances, so it’s worth getting advice rather than assuming the builder carries the risk.
What could happen if copyright is infringed?
The consequences can include court orders affecting the project, damages or an account of profits, as well as the cost of new plans, delays and legal proceedings. Courts can tailor their orders to the circumstances.
Equally, an allegation of infringement doesn’t mean infringement has occurred. The claim, the rights involved and the evidence all need to be assessed properly.
Why this isn’t a do-it-yourself exercise
These questions sit where copyright law, contract interpretation and evidence about how a design came about all meet. Small differences in the facts can change the outcome, and a wrong assumption can become very expensive once building has started.
An intellectual property lawyer can weigh up the factors that apply to your project and tell you where you stand before you commit.
We can assist you
Getting legal advice earlier can help identify risks before they become expensive disputes.
An intellectual property lawyer can examine who owns the copyright, what rights have been granted under the relevant contracts and whether the proposed use of the plans may infringe someone else’s rights.
For example, a lawyer may be able to help by:
- Reviewing building and design agreements to establish who owns the copyright and what the homeowner is permitted to do with the plans.
- Assessing potential infringement by considering the relevant drawings, similarities, evidence of copying and the substantial-part test.
- Negotiating licences or permissions so that plans can be used or adapted lawfully where agreement is possible.
- Advising builders and designers about how to protect their own plans and manage the risks of using existing designs.
- Responding to copyright allegations, including letters of demand, and assessing the available legal arguments and potential remedies.
- Resolving disputes through negotiation, mediation or, where necessary, litigation.
Further Reading
Designing Spaces: Legal Insights for Architects and Interior Designers
https://sharongivoni.com.au/designing-spaces-legal-insights-for-architects-and-interior-designers/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 2: Moral Rights in Architecture: Can You Change an Architect’s Design?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-2-moral-rights-in-architecture/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 2: Moral Rights in Architecture: Can You Change an Architect’s Design?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-2-moral-rights-in-architecture/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 3: When Does a Similar House Design Become Copying?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-3-when-house-designs-look-alike-what-does-the-law-say/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 5: When a Building Project Changes Hands, Who Can Use the Plans?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-5-when-a-building-project-changes-hands-who-can-use-the-plans/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 6: Copyright Letter of Demand? Don’t Panic.
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-6-copyright-letter-of-demand-dont-panic/
Architectural Copyright Series Part 7: Received a Letter of Demand About Your House Design? What It Means and What Happens Next
https://sharongivoni.com.au/architectural-copyright-series-part-7-received-a-letter-of-demand-about-your-house-design/
Australian Institute of Architects – Working with an Architect
https://www.architecture.com.au/explore/working-with-an-architect
Australian Institute of Architects, Acumen – Copyright
https://acumen.architecture.com.au/practice/legislation/copyright
Australian Copyright Council – Building Plans & Copyright, Information Sheet G017v12 (PDF)
https://s3-ap-southeast-2.amazonaws.com/dimoacc/factsheets/INFO017.pdf
The legal blueprint: the laws behind the walls
The main Australian legislation
Key provisions
- Section 10(1) – Interpretation: Defines artistic works, including drawings, plans and buildings.
- Section 14(1) – Acts done in relation to substantial part of work: Explains that references to reproduction and other relevant acts extend to a substantial part of a work.
- Section 21(3) – Reproduction of works: Addresses reproduction of artistic works between two-dimensional and three-dimensional forms.
- Section 31(1)(b) – Nature of copyright in original works: Sets out exclusive rights in relation to artistic works.
- Section 32 – Original works in which copyright subsists: Sets out when copyright protects original artistic works.
- Section 35 – Ownership of copyright in original works: Deals with first ownership and relevant exceptions.
- Section 36 – Infringement by doing acts comprised in the copyright: Addresses infringement and authorisation.
- Section 115 – Actions for infringement: Deals with injunctions, damages, accounts of profits and additional damages.
- Section 196 – Assignment and licences: Addresses the transmission and assignment of copyright, including the requirement that an assignment be in writing and signed by the assignor.
The principal cases
Please note the above article is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Please email us info@iplegal.com.au if you need legal advice about your brand or another legal matter in this area generally.

