Photo by Maria Kozyr on Unsplash
Part 4 of 5 — Food or Medicine?
WHO SHOULD READ THIS?
This article may be particularly relevant to:
- Food and beverage manufacturers and brand owners
- Businesses developing functional foods, snacks and “better for you” products
- Supermarkets, retailers and private-label suppliers
- Packaging designers, marketing agencies and copywriters
- Influencers and content creators working with food brands
- Lawyers, commercial advisers and consultants working in the food sector
If your business talks about the nutritional or health benefits of food, it is helpful to understand how this area is regulated.
Introduction: The Most Valuable Words on the Pack
Walk down any supermarket aisle and you will see them everywhere: “high in protein”, “source of calcium”, “low in sugar”, “supports immunity”.
For food businesses, these few words can be among the most commercially valuable on the pack. They are also among the most closely regulated.
In Part 1 of this series, we looked at how food is regulated in Australia. In Parts 2 and 3, we looked at therapeutic goods and the line between food and medicine.
This article gives a general introduction to health and nutrition claims on food: what they are, where the rules come from and why this area can be more complex than it first appears.
1. What Is a Health or Nutrition Claim?
Broadly, claims on food fall into two families.
Nutrition content claims are about what is, or is not, in a food. Phrases such as “high in fibre” or “low in fat” are familiar examples.
Health claims go further. They are about a relationship between a food, or something in it, and an effect on health. A statement linking calcium to healthy bones is a familiar example.
Claims can appear in many places, including on labels, in advertising, on websites and on social media.
2. Where Do the Rules Come From?
The main source of the rules is Standard 1.2.7 of the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code, titled Nutrition, Health and Related Claims. It is supported by several schedules to the Code, which contain much of the detail.
The rules apply in both Australia and New Zealand, and are developed by Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ).
The Australian Consumer Law also applies to food marketing, so claims are regulated under more than one legal framework.
3. Two Kinds of Health Claims
The Food Standards Code recognises two kinds of health claims.
General level health claims relate to general health effects, rather than serious diseases.
High level health claims relate to a serious disease, or a biomarker of a serious disease.
The two categories are treated differently. FSANZ maintains a list of pre-approved food-health relationships, with more than 200 for general level claims and 13 for high level claims. The Code also contains a process by which businesses can scientifically establish, or “self-substantiate”, certain general level relationships.
FSANZ has emphasised that all health claims are expected to be supported by scientific evidence.
4. It Is Not Just About the Ingredient
One of the features of this area is that the rules look at the food as a whole, not just a single ingredient.
The Code includes a nutrient profiling system that considers the overall nutritional profile of a food. This is one reason why a product containing a beneficial ingredient is not necessarily treated in the same way as another product containing the same ingredient.
5. The Bigger Picture: Consumer Law and the Food–Medicine Line
Food claims also sit within a broader legal landscape.
The Australian Consumer Law prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct. This looks at the overall impression created by packaging and advertising, including images, product names and design, not just individual words.
Many popular marketing words, such as “natural”, “clean” or “superfood”, are not specifically defined in the Food Standards Code. How they are understood can depend on context.
And as we saw in Part 3, the way a product is described can also be relevant to whether it is regulated as a food or as a therapeutic good.
A Lesson from the Courts: ACCC v Heinz
In Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v H.J. Heinz Company Australia Limited [2018] FCA 360, the Federal Court found that the packaging of a toddler snack range conveyed that the products were beneficial to the health of young children, when the products were about two-thirds sugar. Heinz was later ordered to pay $2.25 million in penalties.
The case illustrates that the overall presentation of a product can convey a health message, even without an express health claim.
6. A Changing Landscape
This is an area that continues to evolve.
A current example is the Health Star Rating system, a front-of-pack labelling scheme that is presently voluntary. In February 2026, Food Ministers asked FSANZ to prepare a proposal to make it mandatory. FSANZ is consulting on that proposal, and a final decision is expected in 2027.
FUN FACTS: CLAIMS ON THE PACK
- Over 200 pre-approved food-health relationships exist for general level health claims.
- Only 13 exist for high level health claims.
- It’s not just labels. Claims in advertising are regulated too.
- Two-thirds sugar. That was the toddler snack at the centre of the Heinz case.
- Stars may become compulsory. Health Star Ratings are voluntary for now.
7. Why Health Claims Can Be Complex
Health and nutrition claims are one of the more technical areas of food law because:
- several layers of rules can apply at once
- the type of claim affects how it is treated
- the composition of the particular product matters
- wording, imagery and overall impression can all be relevant
- claims appear across labels, websites, social media and influencer content
- the line between food claims and therapeutic claims is not always obvious
- the rules continue to change
8. Issues That Commonly Arise
Some of the issues that commonly arise in this area include:
- how a particular statement should be characterised
- how the composition of a product interacts with the claims made about it
- whether imagery or presentation conveys an implied message
- how marketing terms that are not specifically defined may be understood
- how claims made online or through influencers are treated
- how food claims relate to the food–medicine boundary
These issues often interact, and how they apply depends on the particular product and circumstances. This article does not address whether any specific claim is permitted.
9. Final Thoughts: Turning Legalese into Legal Ease®
The words on a food pack may be few, but the law behind them is extensive.
Health and nutrition claims sit at the meeting point of food standards, consumer protection law and, sometimes, therapeutic goods regulation. Understanding the basic framework is a useful starting point, but how it applies to a particular product is a question that depends on the detail.
How Sharon Givoni Consulting Can Help
At Sharon Givoni Consulting, we advise food, health and wellness businesses on packaging, labelling, advertising and consumer law issues.
If you have questions about claims on your product or in your marketing, contact us at sharon@iplegal.com.au or visit www.sharongivoni.com.au.
Coming Next in This Series
Part 5 — Marketing Health Products: Social Media, Influencers and the Law
The final article in the series looks at how food and health products are promoted online, and the legal issues that arise when brands, influencers and content creators talk about health.
Key Takeaways
- Claims on food broadly fall into nutrition content claims and health claims.
- The main rules are in Standard 1.2.7 of the Food Standards Code and related schedules.
- Health claims are divided into general level and high level claims.
- The overall nutritional profile of a food can be relevant, not just a single ingredient.
- The Australian Consumer Law applies alongside the food rules.
- Overall presentation can convey a health message.
- The rules continue to evolve, and their application depends on the particular product and circumstances.
Further Reading and Useful Resources
Australian Government and regulatory resources
- FSANZ — Nutrition, health and related claims:
https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/business/labelling/nutrition-health-and-related-claims - FSANZ — Proposal P1067, Health Star Rating System:
https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/food-standards-code/proposals/p1067-health-star-rating-system - Federal Register of Legislation:
https://www.legislation.gov.au/
Case law
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v H.J. Heinz Company Australia Limited [2018] FCA 360:
https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fca/single/2018/2018fca0360 - Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v H.J. Heinz Company Australia Limited (No 2) [2018] FCA 1286:
https://www.judgments.fedcourt.gov.au/judgments/Judgments/fca/single/2018/2018fca1286
Related reading
- Part 1 — Food Law 101: How Is Food Regulated in Australia?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/food-law-101/ - Part 2 — Therapeutic Goods Law 101: How Does the TGA Regulate Medicines, Supplements and Medical Devices?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/therapeutic-goods-law-101/ - Part 3 — Food or Medicine? Where Is the Line?
https://sharongivoni.com.au/food-or-medicine/ - Australian Food Labelling Laws 2025 Made Easy:
https://sharongivoni.com.au/australian-food-labelling-laws/
Australian Laws and Legal Instruments Discussed
- Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code, Standard 1.2.7 — Nutrition, Health and Related Claims, and related schedules
- Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2 — Australian Consumer Law
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand Act 1991 (Cth)
Case discussed
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v H.J. Heinz Company Australia Limited [2018] FCA 360
Please note the above article is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Please email us info@iplegal.com.au if you need legal advice about your brand or another legal matter in this area generally.

