Photo by Supliful Supplements on demand on Unsplash
Part 3 of 5 — Understanding Australia’s Food Laws
There is a Legal Difference in Australia
A herb in your salad. The same herb in a capsule. A vitamin in breakfast cereal. The same vitamin in a tablet. When does a product cross the legal line between food and medicine, and why does it matter?
WHO SHOULD READ THIS?
This article is particularly relevant to:
- Food, beverage, supplement and wellness businesses
- Manufacturers developing new health-related products
- Importers and distributors
- Health food stores, pharmacies and online retailers
- Businesses making nutritional or health-related claims
- Marketing agencies, influencers and content creators
- Lawyers and other professional advisers working with these industries
Whether a business is developing a new product, importing an existing one or reconsidering its marketing, understanding the distinction between food and therapeutic goods can be an important first step.
Introduction: Same ingredient, different law
In Part 1 of this series, we looked at how food is regulated in Australia. In Part 2, we considered the regulation of therapeutic goods, including the role of the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA).
But what happens when a product appears to sit somewhere between the two?
Consider a herb used in cooking and the same herb sold as a concentrated extract. Or a vitamin added to breakfast cereal compared with a vitamin sold in tablet form.
Although the ingredients may be similar, the legal requirements can be very different.
That is because Australian law does not classify products solely by reference to their ingredients. Their formulation, presentation, intended use and the claims made about them may also be relevant.
For businesses, understanding this distinction is important because classification can affect everything from product development and labelling to advertising, importing and selling.
What this article covers — and what it doesn’t
The boundary between food and therapeutic goods is a complex area of Australian law. Although the distinction may appear straightforward, different legal requirements can apply depending on a product’s ingredients, formulation, presentation, intended use and the claims made about it.
This article focuses on the general legal principles that help determine whether a product is regulated as food or as a therapeutic good in Australia.
It considers why classification matters, the role of product presentation and marketing, and some of the practical difficulties businesses may encounter.
It does not attempt to examine every specialised product category, statutory exception or regulatory requirement. Nor does it provide a detailed guide to product approvals, ingredient restrictions, manufacturing standards or advertising compliance. These matters can involve separate and sometimes highly technical legal considerations.
The purpose is to explain the broader regulatory framework and highlight the questions businesses should consider at an early stage, rather than provide definitive answers about particular products.
This approach reflects our motto at Sharon Givoni Consulting, Turning Legalese into Legal Ease®. The aim is to make the law more accessible while recognising that applying it to a particular product may require a more detailed legal assessment.
1. Why does the distinction matter?
Food and therapeutic goods are regulated under different legal frameworks.
In Australia, food is principally regulated through state and territory food legislation and the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code.
Therapeutic goods are regulated primarily under the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth), with the TGA administering the Commonwealth therapeutic goods regulatory framework.
The distinction can affect a range of legal obligations, including:
- Whether a product requires inclusion in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods (ARTG), unless an applicable exemption or other lawful pathway applies
- Which ingredients may be used
- Manufacturing and quality requirements
- Packaging and labelling
- Advertising and promotional claims
- Importation and supply
A product may comply with one set of requirements but not another.
Importantly, determining whether a product is food or a therapeutic good does not, by itself, establish whether it can lawfully be sold.
Classification is only one part of the broader compliance picture.
2. What does the law say?
The starting point is the definition of therapeutic goods in section 3 of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth).
Broadly speaking, the definition considers whether goods are represented, or are likely to be taken, to be for therapeutic use.
Therapeutic use is itself a defined concept and can extend beyond the treatment of illness to other health-related purposes specified in the legislation.
However, the Act also contains important exclusions relevant to food.
These include, subject to the applicable statutory qualifications, goods for which there is a standard in the Food Standards Code and goods with a tradition of use as food for humans in Australia or New Zealand in the form in which they are presented.
Other provisions, including declarations made under section 7 of the Act, may also affect how particular goods are classified.
The important point is that the legal distinction involves more than simply asking whether a product contains a particular ingredient or makes a health-related claim.
A number of factors may need to be considered together.
3. Does the form of a product make a difference?
Yes. The form in which a product is presented can be relevant to its legal classification.
For example, garlic used in cooking is ordinarily understood as food.
However, a concentrated garlic extract sold in capsule form and promoted for particular therapeutic purposes may raise different regulatory questions.
Similarly, a herb sold for culinary use may be treated differently from a concentrated herbal preparation marketed for therapeutic purposes.
The distinction is not simply that one product is a food and the other comes in a capsule.
The legal analysis may involve the product’s composition, its traditional use, the form in which it is presented and the representations made about it.
Packaging, dosage instructions and the way consumers are likely to understand the product can also be relevant.
There is no universal rule that a powder is food or that a capsule is medicine.
The circumstances of the particular product matter.
4. What about advertising and health claims?
How a product is described can be just as important as what it contains.
A product promoted as treating, preventing or relieving a medical condition may raise different legal issues from one promoted as an ordinary food.
Representations made on labels, websites, social media and other advertising materials may all be relevant.
However, even where a product is classified as food, this does not mean that businesses can make unrestricted health claims.
Standard 1.2.7 of the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code regulates nutrition content claims and health claims about food, subject to its scope and applicable requirements.
The Australian Consumer Law, contained in Schedule 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), also prohibits misleading or deceptive conduct and certain false or misleading representations.
These obligations can be relevant regardless of whether a product is food or a therapeutic good.
The consequences of problematic health claims are illustrated by Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lorna Jane Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 852.
In that case, the Federal Court imposed substantial penalties concerning false and misleading representations about the claimed protective properties of clothing.
Although the case did not concern food, it demonstrates the importance of ensuring that health-related marketing representations are legally supportable.
The distinction between permissible food claims and therapeutic claims will be considered further in Part 4 of this series.
5. Are there exceptions to the general rules?
Yes.
Although the definition of therapeutic goods provides an important starting point, the legislation also contains provisions dealing with particular goods and circumstances.
For example, section 7 of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth) provides for declarations concerning whether specified goods or classes of goods are therapeutic goods.
Such declarations can affect the ordinary classification analysis, including where goods might otherwise fall within a food-related exclusion.
This is one reason why general assumptions about particular ingredients or product formats can be unreliable.
A product’s classification may depend on specific legislative provisions that are not immediately apparent from its appearance or marketing.
For the purposes of this article, it is sufficient to recognise that the general distinction between food and therapeutic goods is subject to important statutory qualifications and exceptions.
Those more specialised requirements fall outside the scope of this introductory discussion.
6. What about products imported from overseas?
Businesses importing food, supplements or wellness products into Australia may face additional regulatory considerations.
A product that is lawfully marketed overseas will not necessarily satisfy Australian requirements.
Australia and New Zealand share a joint food standards framework, and the Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition Act 1997 (Cth) provides for mutual recognition of certain goods, subject to applicable exclusions and other legal requirements.
However, the position is not identical for all product categories, and therapeutic goods are treated differently under the mutual recognition arrangements.
For businesses importing products, classification can therefore be particularly important.
The fact that a product is available overseas, or has been accepted under another country’s regulatory system, should not be taken as confirmation that it can lawfully be supplied or advertised in Australia.
7. What happens if a business gets it wrong?
Incorrect classification can have significant legal and commercial consequences.
Depending on the circumstances, a business may face regulatory action concerning the unlawful supply, importation, labelling or advertising of products.
The consequences can include financial penalties, product recalls, changes to packaging or marketing, and interruption to supply.
In Secretary, Department of Health v Evolution Supplements Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 872, the Federal Court imposed substantial penalties for serious contraventions of therapeutic goods legislation, including unlawful advertising and related conduct.
The case involved serious regulatory breaches rather than merely an innocent classification mistake.
Nevertheless, it illustrates the potential consequences of non-compliance with therapeutic goods requirements.
For businesses, the practical consequences may extend beyond penalties.
A product that needs to be reformulated, relabelled or withdrawn can result in considerable expense, particularly where stock has already been manufactured or distributed.
This is why regulatory classification is best considered early in the product development and marketing process.
8. Why can classification be difficult?
There are several reasons why the distinction between food and therapeutic goods can be challenging.
First, the legal frameworks are different and may involve multiple pieces of legislation.
Second, classification can depend on the particular product rather than the general category to which it belongs.
Third, presentation and marketing can influence the legal analysis, meaning that changes to packaging or advertising may have regulatory consequences.
Fourth, particular statutory exclusions, declarations and other requirements may apply.
Finally, the regulatory position can change as legislation and regulatory instruments are amended.
The TGA publishes a Food–Medicine Interface Guidance Tool to assist businesses in considering relevant classification questions.
Although this can be a useful starting point, it is guidance rather than a substitute for the legislation or a definitive legal determination for every product.
9. Questions businesses should be asking
For businesses developing, importing or marketing products that may sit near the food–medicine boundary, relevant questions include:
- How is the product intended to be used?
- What ingredients does it contain, and in what form?
- How will it be presented and marketed?
- What claims will be made about its benefits?
- Is there an applicable food standard?
- Are there relevant statutory exclusions or declarations?
- Does the product require particular regulatory approvals or other compliance steps?
- Could changes to the formulation, packaging or advertising affect its classification?
These are examples of issues that may arise, rather than a comprehensive compliance checklist.
The answers will depend on the product and the applicable legal requirements.
10. Final thoughts
The distinction between food and therapeutic goods is not always obvious.
Products that appear similar may be subject to different legal requirements, and relatively small changes to their formulation, presentation or marketing can have important consequences.
This article has outlined the general principles rather than the many specialised rules and exceptions that can arise.
That distinction is deliberate.
Understanding the framework is a useful starting point, but it is not the same as determining how the law applies to a particular product.
For businesses, the important question is not simply whether something looks like food or medicine, but which regulatory obligations may apply before it is brought to market.
Ultimately, making the law easier to understand does not mean overlooking its complexities. It means identifying the issues that matter and recognising when a more detailed legal assessment may be needed.
That is the thinking behind Turning Legalese into Legal Ease®.
COMING NEXT IN THIS SERIES
Part 4 — Health Claims on Food: What Can You Say?
The next article examines the legal issues surrounding nutrition content claims and health claims on food, including the role of Standard 1.2.7 of the Food Standards Code and the Australian Consumer Law.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Food and therapeutic goods are subject to different regulatory frameworks.
- Classification is not determined by ingredients alone.
- Product formulation, presentation, intended use and marketing can all be relevant.
- Health-related claims may raise issues under food law, therapeutic goods law and the Australian Consumer Law.
- Specific statutory provisions and exceptions may affect classification.
- Products lawfully marketed overseas do not automatically comply with Australian requirements.
- Incorrect classification can create significant legal and commercial risks.
- The appropriate legal analysis depends on the circumstances of the particular product.
FURTHER READING AND USEFUL RESOURCES
Australian Government and regulatory resources
- Therapeutic Goods Administration — Food–Medicine Interface Guidance Tool
- Therapeutic Goods Administration — Understanding how therapeutic goods are regulated
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand — Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission — False or misleading claims
- Federal Register of Legislation — Commonwealth legislation and legislative instruments
THE LAWS DISCUSSED ABOVE
Commonwealth legislation
- Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth), particularly sections 3 and 7
- Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth), Schedule 2 — Australian Consumer Law
- Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition Act 1997 (Cth)
Food standards
- Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code
- Standard 1.2.7 — Nutrition, Health and Related Claims
State and territory legislation
- Applicable state and territory food legislation
- Applicable medicines and poisons legislation
Cases referred to
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Lorna Jane Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 852
- Secretary, Department of Health v Evolution Supplements Australia Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 74
- Secretary, Department of Health v Evolution Supplements Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) [2021] FCA 872
Please note the above article is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.
Please email us info@iplegal.com.au if you need legal advice about your brand or another legal matter in this area generally.

